I got this idea from another website. What you do is, rate the signature above you. Example: who ever posts after me must rate my signature out of 10. You can say why you like it too. Have fun!

EDIT BY MODERATAR! Avatar was added to the title, and this was moved to the chat forum. Just rate the persons avatar and signature above you. That simple.

Avatar : Default. 5/10

Sig : BG is nice and all, could use something, but the stock is FULL SIZE. Its WAAY too large. The colors match well though, but it needs a resize BADLY.
7/10

Avatar: 6/10. It's okay, it's just a bit small.
Signature: 8/10. Nice artistic style.

Avatar: Nothing special. 4/10

Sig: Looks pretty cool. Maybe a bit too much on the large side. 7.5/10

i like your little Samuri person and the way he play with the golf ball. i give it a 8/10 cuz i think its kinda amusing to watch

Avie: Cute lil' animated gyude for the avie. Nothing really special except he mooooves! xDDD <3
7/10
It's adorable, I love it.

Sig: Mmmm, another animated doo-dad. =p It's Rurouni Kenshin batting a ball with his sword, right? I like the chibi-ness of it. But again, nothing too special and I think I've seen that animated gif around before.
7/10

EDIT: Darn you! xDDD This always happens to me.

Avie: Nothing really much except for a cropped pic. Looks angry. *never played FFX-2*
5/10

Sig: Big... o_o Wow, that's big. If you cropped it down and/or resized it, would be more qualified as a sig. xD That's really just an image.
6/10

I dunno, its a weird style. Its done well, but it justs...weird ish.
Since its a set, I'll go in depth on them both and rate them as such.

I think it needs something extra. Not sure what, but I know you can think of something. Otherwise its solid stuff. 8/10

Tooony! Your sets always have such an artistic flare to them. x3

Avie: Looks like a painted effect was added to the stock, I really like it. Muted colours are always a plus in my book! Hot'cha~That's hot. xD 9/10

Sig: Maaaaan, the border is so cool. ;-; I need you to teach me how to do those sometime. The blending is nice and a nice old brown colour! <3 Something could be added, text maybe?
8/10

Pink and anime. Cool. Pink anime!
Avy: 8/10. Small, but pink is a very good colour.
Sig: 9/10. Pink again, and a kitty! I love cats.

Overall: 10/10. Both your avy/sig are pink and pink is a very good colour.

1 for sig, much too large.

1 for avi, generic.

1. I didn't make my sig.
2. I would make an avy, but I'm not very good.

Avy: 9/10. Same reason as sig.
Sig: 9/10. Nice anime style picture and text.

Tony's so afraid of chicks and spastastic underwear sticking out.
Just for spite and my hormones I give your set a ten.
=D

Avatar : What? Its...blurry. o.o Humorous at least. 6/10
Sig : Same as avatar. Just an image. Does its job. 6/10

Kronik is lame as shite.

Avi- 3
Sig- 5


edit- Tony

Avi- 6, it's somewhat decent.
Sig- kinda blandish, 6

Avi: 5 A bit to bland.
Sig: 7 Very vibrant.

-sig 9
-avi 4

Give REASONS Ido, REASONS! You too, Mobius.

Avatar - Standard. Needs a border though. 6/10

Sig - I really dislike those kind of borders, though the transparency helps it a lot. I think a more simple border would have worked for it. The text looks good, and the colors are solid. 6/10

Avatar-9, it looks nice and has a fitting border.

Sig-9 It looks very artistic. Overall, its cool, but a bit blurry. Thats why I didnt give 10.

P.S-I'll be lucky if I get even a 3 for my sig

Avy: 9/10. Very nice.
Sig: 10/10. It's very pretty.

7/10. its a very good sig, but im afraid its too big. but the level of hotness remains the same. anyway, its very good even if it is too big.




btw, jackass & viva la bam are my fav shows. and im not making fun of them with the image in my siggy.

Avatar- 8 becouse it is animated
Sig-9 it is funny and I like jackass the movie too, but your name is not on it.

P.S.- Thanks Rikku for the nice ratings. I'm glad you like it. I'll rate yours when I'll have a chance

Of course I like 'em. Ther'e cool. Did you make them? If you did that's good. I didn't make my sig, and I am sorry it's so big. Wakka made it for me, so he gets all the credit.

Avy: Same as before
Sig: Same as before

Avatar-9 it is pretty.And smiles.
Sig-9 it is a hot chick on it, pretty and all, but it is big

You should try experimenting with Photoshop. I havent got almost any experience and knowledge about it, but Istill managed to make this simple sig. Practice makes perfect.

Avy=4/10=A tad... boring really^^, I would give it a six if it atleast had a black background. (plus, it looks like one of the rpgdreamers default avies.. )

Sig=6/10 (only if u made it´). I´m guessing u made it, since ur hosting it (link in the sig). I like what u did with it, but its still to much of a image, and not a sig.

Avie: 7/10 It looks okay, nothing special, but it is nice.
Sig: 8/10 Looks good imo, I like the chains around it, looks good. =)

Avie: Aw...she's cute. n_n It's got an interesting desing to it, I think it's pretty nifty.
9/10

Sig: Eh, kinda plain. Not a bad thing of course, if minimalism is what you wanted. Not at all!!! I like the darker shade of blue and the text is really nice. Though, the stock isn't the best quality and you have a lot of blank space here and there, I think it's lovely. ;D
8/10

Mmm....I don't like doing overall scores. >.< They make me think of math and averages, so I won't do it.

Cute matching set.

Avi: Nice 80x80 avi. Bit too much on the pinkish side for me.

Sig: Tasteful. Goes together well with your avi.

Avatar-7. It could use some colour

Sig-8 Nice and all, but it is more like an image than a sig, but I gave 8 couse you added below text, wich makes the overall impression better.

Avi- 7 cuz i like the way it looks

Sig - 7 i like the little witch on the broom but it kinda needs a background

overal you get a 7

Avy=6/10: Its an ok avatar, that fits pretty well with the sig, but... Here at dreamers we cant have any big avies (except Eva´s pets )~j/k, don´t ban me ^^
But urs is actually smaller than which we are allowed, not neccesarily a bad thing, its just my oppinion that the bigger, the better (to a certain level of course=P)

Sig=9/10: I so like this one.
1. Beccause blue is my fav color^^
2. The border, altought a tad thick, looks great.
3. Everything within the border fits perfectly.
4. U have managed to make the pic great-looking, even tho it looks like the quality is less than average.

(I´ll only give a 10 to a sig that will literally make me fall down from my chair, and burst out in a happy, yet insane, musical)

LOL, High Standards eh? I'm the same.
Avatar and Sig - Do their job I guess. 8/10. Border around the sig is nice, and it, well, fits. Its k nda blurry though. xD The av is the same thing, but looks a bit bad w/o a border.

I don't expect a high rating of mine since I just slap images in my sig and av since I don't bother to use photoshop or anything.

Sig: I don't like it man, I've seen you with far cooler sigs and yours just looks like some old indian drawing on parchment or something. 7/10

Av: Is confusing... Go back to the Devil Townsend gig. 6/10

I liked your Soilwork one better.

Av - 7/10 Does its job, shows its pic, nothing special.
Sig - Its a movie cover. Badass movie, so it gets an extra point. 8/10

Avi: Don't really like it. No idea who the guy in the avi is. 6/10

Sig: It has style. Seems you've got better at making sigs, eh? 8/10

Both are kind of blah, but they have Al in them.

avi- 6/10
sig- 6/10

Ah #####! I have to do him???
Okay...
avi- 7/10 simple
sig- 9/10 because of the no top or bottom borders.

They Fade into Black, which is a much better effect than borders, IMO. It doesn't have that cut off effect at all.

Avatar 8/10 - Has good colors, but the border is a bit thick.
Signature - It'd be better if it were smaller, and its border wasn't as thick. But its too big and, I don't want to say simple, but I will anyways. 7/10

Gosh Specter yours are always good.

Avi: I like this being clearer than the signature. Its lovely. Both are. 7/10

Signature: I love how this blends though, the pictures really melt into each other which I love. The colours are very earthy and dull but in the good way. 9/10

Nice =)

Here's my rating on your avi and sig Bubble:

Avatar: 8/10 Really small, but very cute and lives up to your name and nature (super cute and bubbly )

Siggy: 9/10 It's very pretty with a grunge/rock twist in it (who's the singer of the band?). It's really good, and I also can't wait to see if you make any more sigs that are like that or are just plain cute.

That's my two cents! Keep up the great avi/sig making!

Avatar-9, nice indeed, interesting looks.

Sig-8, it is original, and the whole sig is effective with all that red.Nice

Avi- 4/10 generic
sig- 5/10, decent but plain.

Avi: 8/10
Signature: 7/10

You should try to make your pieces a little bit more detailed or look like you worked on them than just typing words next to the character

Just a note to Kawaii Angel:

Awww the avi comment is so sweet, thank you <3 LOL and as for the signature, the singer is of Brandon Flowers from The Killers, my favourite band. And boy do I wish I could say i made this signature. I didn't, the lovely Winnie did for my birthday last year because she knew how much I love this band <33

She makes fabulous signatures doesn't she? Shame you can't see the avitar, I cannot for the life of me put it up >_<


As for Hoodie:

Your signature is nice, i really like the edging and the colours of both of them.

Sig: 8/10
Avi: 7/10

avie 9/10 It is Bubble from Bubble and Bobble. One of the cutest avies I have seen it is so cute, I love it. It is such fitting to your name, if you change that one, I'll be crushed =P

sig: 8/10 You still have that one I see, it doesn't match your avie, but none the less it is a pretty good one (good job Winnie =P), can't say anything else then I like it. =)
But I also have to say that I liked the one that Manda made for you, that one did matched your avie, anyway, they're good =)

for some reason, I see the sig and avi and wonder if Pes is really a guy

Avi- 4/10 generic like many others it seems.
Sig- 6/10 I like the colours, but I never understood why the character has to be larger than the rest of the sig in sigs like that.

Lol, despite being a default image, I like it. Its clean, and theres a nice little bg on the background with a good border. It was that way in suikoden and thats how portraits should be done in all games. 8/10 cause you didn't make it.

Sig = Its big. And the Image of Sierra is small, blurry, and a bit pixellated. I can see what was attempted but it really...didn't work? 7/10.

Damn you hugo!

I think I did yours already.
As a set, I love it to death.
The animation is solid, the image is good. My only complaint is that its a bit too large and a bit too dull? o_o Still great work. 8/10

a quick not Tony, Dom did not do my sig, she did my avi and my previous sig. Lem made the current sig.

and though I did yours before, it seems to have changed.

7/10 as a set, but it seems like you just threw something together real quicklike.

Like most people the Avatar and Sig go together well.
I like that effect very much.

Av - 8 (hard to rate these cus of the size, but as far as Avatars go it is really good.)
Sig - 9 Like i said, i like the fact it ties in with the Avatar well. The design is good and the render fits in well. (i also like the little animation you've added in aswell)

ah, very nice. a chick with a gun is always nice. the boarder is nicely done and has a tech look to it. but too blue for my tste

sig: 8/10
ava: 7/10

(the ava is just a smaller photoshoped image that has a reduced section from the sig with a new boarder but its stilll VERY good.)

Avatar - ...al...alright? O.o 8/10. Not sure what it is though, but it does its job.

Sig - It wasn't funny the first time I saw it, its not now. Its just in bad taste, imo. Not to mention theres some loose pixels, and its badly shopped. 4/10