Well, it is a game. Complain about the realism of a 2000 tonne whale fighting an electric mouse.

I know what you mean though. It's kinda between Collesium/Battle Stadium and Gale of Darkness. It's not a full 3D adventure, but nor is it just a pretty add on to other games.
I just watch a video of it. I have to say, it's the best looking Wii game I've seen, by
far. There are some interesting effects and physics going on. None of the attacks showed the Pokemon 'touching', they were all projectile attacks.
One Pokemon used some kind of beam attack, and it melted the floor during the attack and knocked over boxes, and the damage remained. During the next turn the damaged Pokemon was stood inside the still burning crater.
I guess that goes some way to show they are making it more 'solid' and 'believable', the last 2 iterations were just the GB/A games with tarted up visuals. This seems to be a lot more than that.
Lol, I cant get over how good it looked. I guess those comments ATi made about what we saw at E3 being the 'tip of the iceberg" in terms of Wii's power, were true.