These two guys are un-like-able. They both blonded and annoying to some. But they got speed to fight the fastest fiends/enemy. But if they fight each other, who will win and who will be defeated?

Tidus is a star athlete so he should have more speed then zidane.

Both suck really. But in the end I really think Tidus are gonna kick zidane. He is a little more mature and that will do the trick..maybe?!

I am going to say Zidane, cause it is made clearly that Tidus is no swordsman at all and cannot wield a sword.
Also, he is a sportsman, at swimming and kicking a ball, have you seen him running...he is stomping the ground and does actually not run that fast

I would guess Zidane since he has more practical experience with weaponry as a rogue well thief. Tidus is rather arrogant and would likely get himself in trouble.

Even though Zidane is slightly quicker, Tidus I'd have to say is stronger, I think Tidus would kill him... sorry I'm tired...

Mature? Hm... Tidus smells Auron. Tidus listens at doors. Tidus spends 90% of the game blubbering about his dad. Maturity? Not really.

Zidane was able to dodge the Evil Forest attacking him and then later the insane roots of the Iifa Tree. Both speed feats far surpassing Tidus who...swam. That's about it.

And no, Zidane does not suck. He is possibly the greatest hero in the series. Far surpassing the emo losers and mentally-wraped dolts like Tidus, Squall and Cloud.

Zidane wins.

Haha..here we go again..

well..maybe tidus arent very mature, but more than zidane I would say. That little monkey is swinging from tree to tree grabbing princesses buts and is overall very annoying.

I personally found him quite entertaining and deep. His grabbing Garnet's little behind was simply in his nature which is carefree and flirtatious. So he doesn't take everything totally seriously....and he does flirt with woman. Womanizing is not a hallmark of immaturity. Especially when he showed his poetic and deep side i his recounting of the Ipsen story and his own story of his searching for a home to Garnet.

Well..yeah..I guess zidane is entertaining. And he cares for his friends..but still do I think Tidus will take him out..just a feeling..no good reason really. Actually I hope they kill eachother..

Tidus is a teenager who picked up a sword. Sure he played sports. That's just like Joe the Jock picking up a sword and trying to fight.

k.

Zidane is a thief, who wields a knife. In some cut throat societies, I would say he knows how to use it quite well. He has a good agility, as does Tidus. But Zidane was CREATED to be a fighter, so he has it in him. He also has god-like powers, like Kuja, or even better than Kuja. Tidus regular Human or Zidane the Angel of Death 2.0. Hmmm.... The answer is easy to me.

Zidane.