Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: ISPs could face piracy sanctions
RPG Dreamers Forums > Non-Game Related Stuff > General Discussions > News and Discussion Forum
Noir
QUOTE
Internet service providers must take concrete steps to curb illegal downloads or face legal sanctions, the government has said.

The proposal is aimed at tackling the estimated 6m UK broadband users who download files illegally every year.

The culture secretary said consultation would begin in spring and legislation could be implemented "by April 2009".

Representatives of the recording industry, who blame piracy for a slump in sales, welcomed the proposals.

"ISPs are in a unique position to make a difference and in doing so to reverse a culture of creation-without-reward that has proved so damaging to the whole music community over the last few years," said John Kennedy, head of the International Federation of the Phonographic Industry (IFPI).

A spokesperson for the Internet Service Provider's Association (ISPA) said that creating appropriate legislation would be very difficult.

"Any scheme has got to be legal, workable and economically sustainable," the spokesperson told BBC News.

He also said that ISPs were already pursuing self-regulation, which was the government's preferred route.

Privacy issue

"The government has no burning desire to legislate," Andy Burnham, culture secretary, told the Financial Times.

However, he said that the proposals signalled "a change of tone from the government".

Its intentions are outlined in a creative industries strategy paper called Creative Britain: New Talents for the New Economy.

The document is a broad ranging paper that sets out government support for the creative industries.

The document commits the government to consulting on anti-piracy legislation this spring "with a view to implementing it by April 2009", according to the FT.

"We're saying we'll consult on legislation, recognising there are practical questions and legitimate issues," Mr Burnham told the paper.

In particular, any legislation would have to take account of the 2002 E-Commerce Regulations that define net firms as "conduits" which are not responsible for the contents of the traffic flowing across their networks.

European laws on online privacy could also create problems for any new legislation.

Earlier this year it was reported that the government was considering a "three strikes" approach to tackling persistent offenders in the report.

But Mr Burnham denied this was the case and told the FT that the strategy had "never been in the paper".

If the government goes ahead, the UK would be one of the first countries to impose sanctions.

"This is a sea-change in attitude and I believe it is now up to governments elsewhere in Europe and further afield to follow their example," said Mr Kennedy.


http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/technology/7258437.stm


They're coming for you.
Razael
##### cunts, let me download my porn for free in peace.
Noir
You could just take a bunch of free tours.
Athrun
Good thing I live in Sweden then.
Nash
What's the big fuss with piracy?

Case in point, the artwork business has been going on forever and artwork lovers do value originals highly. No matter how well done fakes may be, the originals always reign supreme. And the best quality artworks actually appreciate with time. (i.e. Like how Mona Lisa is Mona Lisa. No matter how many "bootleg" versions of that picture are spread around, the original is still the only one that matters!)

Time to replicate that kind of quality in other artsy businesses? Assuming that recording companies could actually produce quality products worthy of being compared to artworks, of course.
Noir
Ken Masters
QUOTE (Noir @ Feb 23 2008, 10:16 AM) *
You could just take a bunch of free tours.

That just sucks though. Free tours always suck.
Logain
If I were a musician, I think I would rather have 1 million people download my music for free than just having 1,000 buying it. It should be about sharing the music, after all.
Valince
Some music artists do share that view you have. Some however see it as potential sales not being made. Getting overanal about privacy is becoming stupider and stupider every year. YOU CANNOT STOP PEOPLE FROM DOWNLOADING #####. Even if you shut the internet down, people will still find a way.
Pesmerga
Moving back to the Netherlands \o/

In other words, people are being anal again. I always say, people wouldn't download if things weren't so expensive.
Take a look at Adobe Photoshop, or Premiere Pro, love the porgrams, but I am not paying THAT much money for a program that basically does the same as the free WMM, just with advanced options.

Companies like that are full of themselves. Same with OS Windows, that much money, for simply an OS, which you can get free if you would go for a Unix based system.
They need to remove the thumb that is up their arse.
Bomb
QUOTE (Noir @ Feb 23 2008, 02:07 PM) *
QUOTE
Representatives of the recording industry, who blame piracy for a slump in sales, welcomed the proposals.


Figures that they wouldn't blame the overall shitty quality of current mainstream music for the slump in sales.

Not to mention that the US is in an ecomomic recession overall right now, so people--you know--like, don't have the same kind of spending money they used to have.

What a pretentious bunch of cocks the recording industry is made of.

Also
Apple_Juice
QUOTE (Razael @ Feb 23 2008, 11:11 AM) *
##### cunts, let me download my porn for free in peace.

you can still stream. at least I hope.

btw, what I think of this: this ##### sucks ass
Natsuki
This technically doesn't refer to the US at all x_x.

QUOTE (techcrunch)
Japan has decided to beat France and the United Kingdom (both who have similar proposals) to become the first country to ban file sharers from the internet.

Oddly the agreement to do so has not come from the Japanese Government, but from Japan’s four internet service provider organizations after pressure (not surprisingly) from the record and movie industries. According to Torrent Freak, the agreement would see copyright holders tracking down file-sharers on the Internet using “special detection software” and then notifying ISPs of alleged infringers. File sharers will initially receive a warning for a first offense, then be disconnected for subsequent offenses, eventually be disconnected from the internet permanently (it wasn’t clear whether the agreement is a three strikes proposal).

The process will formally commence in April and will primarily target users of Winny, the most popular file sharing network in Japan.


No more anime? No more dorama's? No more J-Music?
Ken Masters
QUOTE (Winnie @ Mar 22 2008, 05:21 PM) *
This technically doesn't refer to the US at all x_x.

QUOTE (techcrunch)
Japan has decided to beat France and the United Kingdom (both who have similar proposals) to become the first country to ban file sharers from the internet.

Oddly the agreement to do so has not come from the Japanese Government, but from Japan’s four internet service provider organizations after pressure (not surprisingly) from the record and movie industries. According to Torrent Freak, the agreement would see copyright holders tracking down file-sharers on the Internet using “special detection software” and then notifying ISPs of alleged infringers. File sharers will initially receive a warning for a first offense, then be disconnected for subsequent offenses, eventually be disconnected from the internet permanently (it wasn’t clear whether the agreement is a three strikes proposal).

The process will formally commence in April and will primarily target users of Winny, the most popular file sharing network in Japan.


No more anime? No more dorama's? No more J-Music?

People will find a way to file share, it always happens.
KCshushu
Bleh...I'm not worried.

The music I adore and love isn't the kind you can download anyways. I do my part to support local bands and musicians by getting out there and paying for tickets to see good music LIVE.

I doubt I'll see that in my country any time soon...I hope
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.