QUOTE (Forcystus26 @ Apr 24 2008, 06:05 PM)

Before I begin my rant I have to remind you Pesmerga that the point of discussion between you and me now is this question:
"Can an outsider openly critisize the ways of an independant nation, (China in this case), or protest against the way they 'manage' their country. "
I thought the topic was about something else, but whatever floats your boat.
CODE
So PESMERGA, if you bring up the bloody and cruel past of the Netherlands, that's COMPLETELY off topic, if a Chinese would start critisizing our 17th century slave trade I'd LET him, I'd agree with him and allow him to speak his mind about it.
Actually, you brought up things from the past, I simply added to it. The reason is quite simple. You point your finger to China, whereas most succesful countries took land, slaughtered people, far worse than any other country did.
Do I need to remind you about all the Indians slaughtered? See, if you bring up things from the past, in your case the Holocaust and Nazis, then go all the way.
CODE
"Don't talk as if China is the only country which has annexed countries etc.." I never did such a thing.
"Every country takes and loses land, it is a fact. " I never denied this, the question is if it's "right" or not.
It depends. Is the country in decline? Does it need help? Is it better off if it is a part of another country.
Let me ask you a theoretical question: "Is it better if Belgium splits up in two and merge with the Netherlands and France?" I know that certain Belgians want to, what do you think?
CODE
"Are we superior to other races? Are we elite to them?" -Actually if you read my post on the first page you can see that I clearly said that I DON'T think the West is superior, so I don't understand why you are saying this.
It is because you keep saying things as: "In the West we ...." Sounds you're talking about us being better. As I said before, do not compare the West and the East together.
CODE
"How can you say, with an honest face and 100% truthfully that you what you see on the tele is the exact truth."
I never said this so I don't know why you are saying this, again.
How much do you know, about what is happening in China?
CODE
-(I don't want to go into details but if you come up with that "my house my rules" scenario I play along".)
"You cannot judge what happens in China, as I cannot judge what happens in your house." Be careful with saying this because if you say this you mean that IF I would see you beating up your kid in YOUR house. And later I'd say to you " hey, I don't like the way you treat your kids, you should stop or i'll call the child police" (or whatever).
You are saying that I can't do that because it's your house and your rules. Wel if that's what you think, I think you have a serious problem with your way of thinking, a sane person would agree with me critisizing your way of treating your child.
Let me rephrase that for you. How the government gave you your own rules in your house. You have different rules and pay different taxes. Now, think that scenario again. Is it in my right to stand with 100 activist and rant and rave about you, theoretically, beating a kid? Even if I have no grounded proof?
CODE
"And yes, sometimes it is better to forbid things from being talked about."
Good job! You are now in fase 1 of becoming a communist, this is exactly the kind of theory a Communist would agree with.
You can NOT forbid those thing in a FREE country.
Ermmm, no seriously. Some things aren't need to be said and are better if they remain silent. Has nothing to do with Communism, or freedom of speech. Just because you can it doesn't mean you have. Some things are better if they're kept private.
Good example, the nude pictures that leaked on the internet in China. Do you think they're better off out in the open? Or should they have kept hidden? I know it isn't exactly the same, but you get my point, I hope.
CODE
"Do you really have a clue to what you talk about?" I'm guessing this is a rhethorical question so I"m not going to reply to it, this is very weak of you.
Actually, you started it.
CODE
Lastly Pesmerga, one more thing,
"This is called Communism, my fellow Dutchie, that means diffirent rules. It is how the country is build, same as with countries such as Russia and Korea, but you don't talk about those countries" this is what you said,
and frankly, I don't want to go into details but since 1989 Russia has become a kapitalist nation, and only North Korea is communist. But to the point, I'm not talking about those other communist countries because this thread is called I believe, THE OLYMPIC GAMES IN CHINA, maybe you didn't see that last word mate but that's what it's about in this thread, not Vietnam or North-Korea or whatever. So please stay on TOPIC.
Speaking of on-topic. Didn't you just changed the discussion earlier in your post? Seriously, if you start being contradicting already, there is no point in even bothering to reply.
CODE
Please do not take me for a fool, you don't need an IQ of 140+ to know that China is an UNFREE country and that they keep their people tied to a rope. I don't need to be able to speak Chinese to know that the quality of Human Rights in China is really bad. You have to stop living in a dream and face the reality, even if it is an unpleasant one.
Erm... you seem to know an awful lot about China. Where did you gather this information, other than the news? As I asked before, how can you be 100% certain, that everything you just claimed is 100% accurate and based on facts?
I am not making any claims about China, because I can't say that I have been there, nor truly know what is going on, yet you do.
I know Winnie can, because she is Chinese.
CODE
Also please have a little bit more in the media, stop thinking it's a set-up and that the media is "evil", we're not living in a science-fiction novel.
The media is not the ultimate form of truth. Media often spins things around, especially when it comes down to numbers.
QUOTE (Denim @ Apr 24 2008, 07:00 PM)

How can you say with an honest face that almost everything on it is a lie? Do you believe in the Illuminati? Do you think the Tienamen square protests and massacres never happened, or something? Those alone are proof of China's insanity.
Not saying it is. Where did I say that? And as what was said earlier, every country has/had its problems. I mean, America invading Iraq, the Netherlands starting slavery. We all have our moments, but that doesn't mean that a country is "insane" all of a sudden.
Just because you can't grasp it, doesn't mean they are the fool. Just to make a funny statement, I think they think the West are "insane" and that we're being the "insane" ones.